Phenomenon, I had no idea what this show was about until I watched it online. Actually after watching the first full episode, it appears to be a magician type reality show.

More about Phenomenon
“Ten magicians and mentalists compete for top honors for supernatural sensation judges Criss Angel and Uri Geller. Fans are challenged with figuring out how the contestants perform their tricks, and whether any are based on real psychic abilities. Users can participate through forums and interactive games.” -Tv.com

Where to watch Phenomenon Online
Phenomenon’s full episodes can be watched online via this link.